Red Tailed Hawk Vs Red Shouldered Hawk: Key Differences Revealed (2024)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

You’ll notice key differences between Red-tailed hawks and Red-shouldered hawks in their size, appearance, and behavior.

Red-tailed hawks are larger with broader wings and a brick-red tail, while red-shouldered hawks are more compact with squared-off wingtips and a black-and-white banded tail.

Red-tailed hawks prefer open spaces and hunt larger prey, whereas red-shouldered hawks inhabit wooded areas and target smaller creatures.

Their vocalizations differ too: red-tailed hawks emit a high-pitched "kee-kee-kee," while red-shouldered hawks have a louder, piercing "kee-aah" call.

These distinctions help birdwatchers identify these majestic raptors in the wild. Stick around to uncover more fascinating contrasts between these two impressive birds of prey.

Size and Shape

When you’re out birdwatching, size and shape are key to distinguishing between red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks.

You’ll notice the red-tailed hawk is the bigger of the two, with a robust body and broad, rounded wings. Its tail length is proportionate to its size, giving it a balanced silhouette in flight.

On the other hand, the red-shouldered hawk is more compact, sporting a slimmer profile with distinctive squared-off wingtips. This smaller raptor has a relatively longer tail, which can help you spot it even from a distance.

As you observe their body shapes, pay attention to the red-tailed’s stockier build compared to the red-shouldered’s more streamlined form. These size comparisons are essential for identification, especially when feather patterns aren’t clearly visible.

Color Patterns

Now that we’ve covered size and shape, let’s explore the vibrant world of these magnificent raptors. You’ll be amazed at how their plumage patterns can help you identify them in the wild.

The red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks display striking morphological features and plumage variations that set them apart:

• Red-tailed hawks sport a distinctive brick-red tail, visible in flight
• Red-shouldered hawks have a unique checkered pattern on their upper wings
• Adult red-tailed hawks often have dark markings on their stomach
• Red-shouldered hawks showcase reddish-orange underparts
• Both species exhibit different eye colors, adding to their unique appearances

These color patterns aren’t just for show – they play a key role in habitat partitioning and camouflage. Despite their range overlap, these hawks have adapted their plumage to suit their preferred environments. By mastering these visual cues, you’ll gain the ability to identify these birds with confidence, even in areas where their territories intersect.

Habitats and Preferences

Regarding habitats and preferences, red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks exhibit notable differences. Red-tailed hawks, with their adaptability, thrive in various environments. They soar above open spaces, perch on telephone poles, and scan fields from treetops. Their presence is widespread, ranging from prairies to urban outskirts.

In contrast, red-shouldered hawks favor wooded areas, especially moist deciduous forests. These elegant birds are frequently found near water bodies or in suburban areas with mature trees. Their distribution is more confined compared to red-tailed hawks.

Both species face challenges due to habitat loss, prompting conservation initiatives to protect their ecosystems. Consider these actions to support these magnificent raptors:

• Participate in local sightings and bird counts
• Support habitat preservation initiatives
• Reduce pesticide use in your yard
• Educate others about the environmental impact of urban expansion

Hunting Behavior

Regarding hunting behavior, red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks employ distinct strategies. You’ll notice that red-tailed hawks frequently hunt from exposed perches or while soaring, scanning open areas for prey. They’re masters of the swift dive, using their powerful talons to snatch unsuspecting victims. Red-shouldered hawks, on the other hand, prefer to hunt from concealed perches within forests, ambushing their prey with surprising agility.

In areas where their ranges overlap, you might witness food competition between these raptors. However, their differing prey sizes and habitat preferences often minimize direct conflicts, allowing both species to thrive as formidable birds of prey.

Migration Patterns

When it comes to migration patterns, you’ll notice some key differences between red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks. Red-tailed hawks are year-round residents in the Southeast, while their northern counterparts often migrate south for winter. Red-shouldered hawks, however, typically move north for summer breeding.

You’ll find red-tailed hawks adapting to various habitats along their journey, from open fields to urban areas. Red-shouldered hawks stick closer to forested regions, even during migration. By understanding these patterns, you’ll gain a deeper appreciation for these magnificent birds of prey and their incredible journeys across the continent.

Vocalizations

You’ll notice distinct vocalizations when comparing red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks. The red-tailed hawk emits a high-pitched "kee-kee-kee" call, while the red-shouldered hawk produces a louder, more piercing "kee-aah" vocalization.

Red-tailed Hawk: High-pitched Kee-kee-kee

You’ll recognize the Red-tailed Hawk’s voice by its high-pitched "kee-kee-kee" call. This distinctive vocalization sets it apart from its cousin, the Red-shouldered Hawk.

While soaring on broad wings or perched atop a pole, these raptors use their calls to communicate with mates and defend territory.

The kee-kee-kee sound is shorter and less piercing than other hawk species, making it a unique identifier in the wild.

Red-shouldered Hawk: Loud, Piercing Kee-aah Call

You’ll know a Red-shouldered Hawk by its loud, piercing "kee-aah" call. This distinctive vocalization sets it apart from its cousin, the Red-tailed Hawk.

When you hear this sharp cry echoing through the forest, you’re witnessing the hawk’s territorial behavior in action. These piercing vocalizations are a key part of their vocal communication, helping them establish dominance and protect their turf.

Listen closely – nature’s symphony is at play!

Nesting and Mating

You’ll find that both red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks construct stick nests for breeding, but their chosen locations differ slightly. Red-tailed hawks typically build their nests in tree crotches, while red-shouldered hawks prefer to nest in tall trees, often near water sources.

Red-tailed Hawk: Breeds in Stick Nests in Tree Crotches

You’ll find Red-tailed Hawks nesting in the perfect sweet spot: tree crotches. These avian architects construct their homes with precision and care. Here’s what you need to know about their nesting habits:

1. Nest location: Typically 35-75 feet above ground
2. Branch height: Often in the upper third of the tree
3. Nest materials: Sticks, bark strips, and fresh greenery
4. Nest size: Impressive structures up to 3 feet wide and 3 feet deep

Red-shouldered Hawk: Breeds in Stick Nests in Tall Trees

You’ll find Red-shouldered Hawks nesting in tall trees, often near water. They’re picky about their real estate, choosing spots 20-60 feet up. Here’s a quick look at their nesting habits:

Aspect	Details
Nest Material	Sticks, bark, moss
Incubation Time	28-33 days
Clutch Size	2-5 eggs
Fledgling Care	6-7 weeks

Both parents share nest-building, incubation, and feeding duties. Their strong maternal instincts guarantee the chicks’ survival in the wild.

Diet

Regarding diet, Red-tailed and Red-shouldered Hawks have distinct prey preferences and foraging techniques. You’ll find Red-tailed Hawks hunting in open areas, often swooping down on unsuspecting prey. Their diet consists mainly of:

• Small to medium-sized mammals like rabbits and squirrels
• Birds, including starlings and pheasants
• Reptiles such as snakes and lizards
• Occasionally, carrion or roadkill

Red-shouldered Hawks, on the other hand, prefer forested habitats near water bodies. Their menu is more diverse, reflecting their adaptability. They feast on:

• Small mammals like voles and mice
• Amphibians, particularly frogs and salamanders
• Insects, including grasshoppers and beetles
• Crustaceans like crayfish

Both species have evolved digestive adaptations to handle their varied diets efficiently. Their nutritional requirements are met through these prey choices, which are closely tied to their preferred habitats. Understanding these diet interactions helps explain their distribution and behavior in different ecosystems.

Lifespan

You’ll find that red-tailed hawks generally live longer than their red-shouldered counterparts, with a maximum lifespan of about 30 years compared to 25 years. This difference in longevity can be attributed to various factors, including the red-tailed hawk’s larger size and ability to adapt to a wider range of habitats.

Red-tailed Hawk: Up to 30 Years

You’ll be astonished to learn that red-tailed hawks can live up to 30 years in the wild. Their extended lifespan has a substantial impact on breeding habits and population patterns.

As you explore their range overlap with other species, you’ll discover how this lifespan contributes to genetic diversity. However, habitat loss poses a threat to their survival.

These majestic birds are a testament to nature’s resilience, adapting to various environments throughout their three-decade journey.

Red-shouldered Hawk: Up to 25 Years

You’ll find Red-shouldered Hawks living up to 25 years in the wild. Like their red-tailed cousins, these birds are resilient survivors.

During their lifetime, you’ll hear their distinctive "kee-aah" call echoing through forests. They’ll mate for life, raising chicks year after year.

Their striking orange underparts will fade slightly with age, but their hunting skills remain sharp. These hawks truly master the art of longevity in the avian world.

Distinguishing Features

You’ll notice key differences in size, body shape, wing patterns, and tail characteristics when comparing red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks. The red-tailed hawk is larger with broader wings and a brick-red tail, while the red-shouldered hawk has a more compact body with distinctive checkered wings and a black-and-white banded tail.

Size And Body Shape

You’ll spot key differences in size and shape between these two hawks.

Red-tailed hawks are the heavyweights, tipping the scales at 800g to 1.2kg, with an impressive wingspan up to 135cm. Their red-shouldered cousins are more svelte, weighing 550-700g with a 91-101cm wingspan.

Red-tails boast a larger, broader build, while red-shoulders have a slimmer profile. These body proportions are essential for quick identification in the field.

Wing And Tail Patterns

You’ll notice distinct wing and tail patterns when identifying these hawks. Red-tailed hawks sport:

1. Broad, rounded wings
2. Short, fan-shaped tails
3. Dark patagial marks along the leading edge of wings

Red-shouldered hawks, however, have forward-arching wings with squared-off tips. Their longer tails display striking black and white bands. In flight, you’ll spot translucent crescents near their wingtips, a telltale sign of this species’ unique feather color and banding patterns.

Underpart Color Differences

When identifying these hawks, focus on their underpart colors. You’ll notice distinct differences:

Feature	Red-tailed Hawk	Red-shouldered Hawk
Breast	Pale	Reddish
Belly	White	Orange-red
Barring	Dark, sparse	Fine, reddish
Undertail	Pale	Black and white

Red-tailed hawks have pale breasts with sparse dark barring, while red-shouldered hawks boast reddish underparts with fine barring. The red-shouldered’s striking black and white banded tail is a dead giveaway.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)