Red Tailed Hawk Vs Red Shouldered Hawk: 8 Key Differences (2025)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

When comparing red tailed hawk vs red shouldered hawk, size tells the story immediately. Red-tailed hawks are the heavyweights, sporting broader wings and bulkier frames that make them unmistakable soaring overhead.

Red-shouldered hawks are more compact, with distinctive squared-off wings that arch forward slightly. The tail patterns seal the deal—red-tails flash that famous rusty-red tail (hence the name), while red-shouldered hawks sport bold black and white bars across their tails.

You’ll also notice red-shouldered hawks have that characteristic reddish shoulder patch that gives them their identity. Their calls differ too, with red-tails delivering harsh "keeeeeer" screams versus the red-shouldered’s repetitive "kee-ah" notes.

Understanding these visual cues and behavioral quirks transforms confusing hawk encounters into confident identifications.

Hawk Size Comparison

When you’re trying to tell red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks apart, size becomes your first reliable clue in the field.

Red-tailed hawks are noticeably larger and bulkier, with females weighing up to 3.2 pounds compared to red-shouldered hawks that max out around 1.7 pounds.

Red-tailed hawks pack nearly twice the weight of their red-shouldered cousins, making size your best field identification clue.

Red-tailed Hawk Measurements

The red tailed hawk stands as North America’s largest buteo, showcasing impressive measurements that distinguish it from other hawk species.

Males typically weigh 1.5-2.9 pounds, while females reach 1.8-3.8 pounds.

Their wingspan stretches 43-56 inches, making them formidable soaring predators.

The red tailed hawk’s physical characteristics, including its hawk eye features, play a vital role in its hunting success.

Measurement	Males	Females
Body Mass	1.5-2.9 lbs	1.8-3.8 lbs
Wing Length	Under 45 inches	48-54 inches
Tail Size	7.4-10.2 inches	7.4-10.2 inches

Red-shouldered Hawk Measurements

When you’re studying hawk species comparison, you’ll discover that red shouldered hawks are markedly smaller than their red-tailed cousins.

Their woodland hunters typically measure 15-24 inches in length with a wingspan reaching 37-43 inches. Their compact build reflects their red shouldered hawk habitat preferences for dense forests where maneuverability matters more than raw power.

Measurement	Range
Body Length	15-24 inches
Wing Length	37-43 inches
Body Mass	1.1-1.9 pounds

Their tail size averages 7.4-9.4 inches, providing excellent steering through canopy gaps. Females typically outweigh males by 10-12%, supporting their role as nest defenders.

The beak shape remains compact yet efficient for their red shouldered hawk diet of small mammals and amphibians. These proportions create distinctive feather patterns that aid identification during bird size comparisons.

Size Differences Between Species

Size differences between these hawk species become apparent when you compare their measurements side by side.

Red-tailed hawks clearly outweigh their red-shouldered cousins, with females showing the most dramatic size variation.

This sex dimorphism affects hunting strategies and territorial behavior patterns.

Measurement	Red-tailed Hawk	Red-shouldered Hawk
Body Mass	1.5-3.2 lbs	1.1-1.7 lbs
Wing Span	45-52 inches	37-44 inches
Tail Length	Short, wide	Medium, banded
Overall Length	18-26 inches	16-24 inches

Plumage and Color

You’ll notice striking color differences between these two hawk species that make field identification much easier once you know what to look for.

The most obvious distinction lies in their tail patterns and shoulder coloring, which give each species its distinctive name.

Red-tailed Hawk Color Patterns

Throughout the Red-tailed Hawk‘s impressive range, you’ll notice distinctive color patterns that set this hawk species apart.

Their plumage showcases remarkable variation, making bird identification techniques essential for accurate recognition:

1. Tail Feathers: Rich rusty-red coloration visible from above and below
2. Wing Tips: Prominent black markings contrasting against lighter underwings
3. Head Plumage: Brown streaking with cream-colored throat patches

These Feather Texture variations help distinguish them from Redshouldered Hawks, while their Beak Color remains consistently dark yellow.

Red-shouldered Hawk Color Variations

You’ll notice dramatic plumage patterns that set red-shouldered hawks apart from their red-tailed cousins.

Their hawk species differences become clear when you observe their distinctive color morphs – adults display rich reddish-brown shoulders contrasting with black-and-white checkered wing bars.

Their tail feathers show bold alternating bands of black and white, creating striking plumage variation that makes bird identification techniques more straightforward than you’d expect, with dramatic plumage patterns and distinctive color morphs.

Underpart Color Differences

Looking at underpart color differences provides your clearest identification clues when distinguishing these hawk species.

Red tailed hawk displays a mostly white belly with a distinctive dark band across the breast feathers, while red shouldered hawk shows consistent rusty-orange coloring throughout its underparts.

The tail underside reveals rust-colored feathers in red tailed hawks versus brown and white banding in red shouldered hawks.

Wing linings appear pale in red tailed hawks but show rufous coloring in red shouldered species, which is a key factor in distinguishing between these two hawk species.

Vocalization Patterns

You’ll hear these hawks before you see them, and their calls provide reliable identification clues that work even when visual details are unclear.

Trust your ears when visual identification fails – these hawks announce themselves with signature calls that cut through forest noise.

Each species has distinct vocal patterns that reflect their different behaviors and temperaments in the wild, which can be considered as reliable identification clues.

Red-tailed Hawk Calls

You’ll recognize a Red-tailed Hawk by its distinctive harsh scream – a descending "keeeeer" that lasts 2-3 seconds.

This iconic bird vocalization appears frequently in movies as sound effects for eagles, though it’s actually the Red-tailed Hawk’s territorial call.

Red-shouldered Hawk Vocalizations

Red-shouldered hawks break into their signature "kee-aah" calls during territorial disputes and courtship rituals.

Their bird vocalizations peak during breeding season, with auditory cues serving as mate communication tools.

Feature	Description
Call Pattern	Repeated "kee-aah" sequence
Frequency Range	2-3 kHz dominant pitch
Seasonal Peak	February-May breeding months
Daily Activity	Morning/afternoon hours

Differences in Hawk Screams

When you hear hawk screams echoing through the forest, frequency analysis reveals distinct vocal patterns that separate these species.

Red tailed hawk produces a single, hoarse "keeeeer" lasting 2-3 seconds, while red shouldered hawk delivers a two-note "kee-yaah" with descending pitch.

These call types create unique sound waves – red shouldered hawk vocalizations are higher, clearer, and more repetitive than their red-tailed cousins’ piercing scream.

Understanding the hawk screech vocalization patterns is essential for identifying and studying these bird species with distinct vocal patterns.

Habitat and Behavior

Where you spot these hawks reveals their distinct lifestyles – red-tailed hawks patrol open countryside from telephone poles, while red-shouldered hawks prefer dense woodlands near water.

Their hunting tactics differ just as dramatically, with red-tails soaring high above fields and red-shoulders ambushing prey from forest perches.

Red-tailed Hawk Habitats

You’ll find Redtailed Hawks thriving across diverse bird habitats and ecosystems throughout North America.

These adaptable raptors flourish in Desert Habitats, Forest Ecosystems, Mountain Terrain, and Urban Landscapes. Their hawk habitat preferences include open country with scattered perches – think farmland, roadside corridors, and suburban parks.

Red-tailed Hawk habitat spans from sea level to 10,000 feet, making raptor conservation efforts essential across varied Wetland Areas and grasslands where they hunt effectively.

Understanding bird habitat needs is essential for installing bird habitat cameras to monitor their behavior, which is crucial for effective conservation and management of these ecosystems.

Red-shouldered Hawk Preferences

Unlike their red-tailed counterparts, red shouldered hawks prefer mature deciduous and mixed woodlands near water sources.

You’ll find them in bottomland hardwood forests, swampy areas, and riparian corridors throughout eastern North America.

These raptors show remarkable tolerance for suburban development, frequently nesting in wooded parks and residential areas with adequate tree cover and minimal disturbance during breeding seasons.

Their ability to thrive in various habitats is influenced by their adaptation strategies, which is a key factor in their success in different environments, including wooded parks and residential areas.

Hunting Behavior Comparison

These hunting masters employ vastly different strategies when pursuing prey.

Red-tailed hawks rely on patient perch-hunting and soaring surveillance, while red-shouldered hawks excel at ambush tactics from mid-canopy positions.

Understanding effective hawk hunting requires knowledge of proper Hawk Hunting Gear.

Key Hunting Behavior Differences:

1. Flight Patterns – Red-tailed hawks soar high using thermals; red-shouldered hawks make short, quick flights through dense woods
2. Prey Capture – Red-tails dive from heights onto ground prey; red-shoulders strike from concealed perches near water
3. Hunting Success – Red-tails achieve 10-20% success rates; red-shoulders average 5-12% but hunt more frequently
4. Ambush Tactics – Red-shoulders use surprise attacks in cluttered forests; red-tails prefer open-ground visual tracking

Key Identification Features

When you’re watching hawks in the field, three key features will help you quickly tell these species apart.

Focus on body shape, wing patterns, and their distinctive calls to make confident identifications every time.

Size and Body Shape

When you’re sizing up these raptors, think of it like comparing a linebacker to a gymnast.

Red-tailed hawks pack more muscle into their stockier frames, while red-shouldered hawks sport a sleeker, more athletic build that’s perfectly suited for woodland acrobatics.

Understanding key bird identification features is essential for distinguishing between these two species.

Feature	Red-tailed Hawk	Red-shouldered Hawk
Body Proportions	Chunky, barrel-shaped	Lean, streamlined
Wing Span	45-52 inches	37-44 inches
Tail Length	Short, wide	Long, narrow

Wing and Tail Patterns

You’ll spot these hawks by their distinctive wing shapes and tail length differences.

Red-tailed hawks display broad, rounded wings with a short, wide tail that’s rust-colored above. Red-shouldered hawks show narrower wings with a longer, banded tail featuring bold black-and-white stripes.

In flight, red-shouldered hawks reveal translucent crescents near their wing tips, while red-tailed hawks maintain steadier flight patterns with seamless wing-to-tail movements.

Understanding hawk wing shape variations is vital for accurate identification of these bird species.

Distinguishing Vocalizations

You can tell these hawks apart by their distinct vocal patterns.

Red-tailed hawk calls sound like a single, hoarse "keeeeer" scream lasting 2-3 seconds – that’s the classic raptor sound you hear in movies.

Red-shouldered hawk vocalizations are completely different: a clear, two-note "kee-yaah" call repeated several times.

The red-shouldered’s higher-pitched screaming habits make them much more vocal than their red-tailed cousins, which is a key difference in their vocal behaviors.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)