Red-Tailed Vs Red-Shouldered Hawk: ID Guide & Key Differences (2026)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

You’ve probably spotted a rust-tailed hawk wheeling over a highway median and wondered which species just caught your eye. Both red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks patrol similar territories across North America, yet they’re built for entirely different worlds.

Red-tails dominate open country with bulk and power, claiming grasslands and agricultural edges, while red-shouldered hawks slip through wooded corridors near water, hunting with precision in dappled forest light. Their contrasting hunting styles, plumage patterns, and vocalizations reveal two distinct evolutionary paths—and learning to distinguish them transforms every roadside raptor from a generic “hawk” into a specific story about habitat, prey, and survival strategy.

Size and Physical Differences

The first step in telling these two raptors apart is understanding their physical build, because red-tailed hawks are noticeably bulkier than their red-shouldered cousins.

Red-tails typically have broader wings and a stockier chest compared to the slimmer profile of an osprey bird, which also differs in hunting style and build.

You’ll find clear differences in wingspan, body length, and weight that can help you identify which hawk you’re watching. Let’s break down the measurements for each species and look at how males compare to females.

If you’re more drawn to colorful, social birds, exploring the different types of parrots might lead you to your perfect feathered friend.

Red-tailed Hawk Measurements

The red-tailed hawk (Buteo jamaicensis) ranks among North America’s larger hawk species, and you’ll recognize its commanding presence through these precise measurements:

Their plumage also features distinctive red, black, and white patterns similar to those found in woodpeckers of Colorado.

1. Wing span: Generally 110 to 141 cm, creating that broad soaring silhouette
2. Tail length: Ranges from 18.8 to 25.9 cm in adults
3. Body mass: Adults weigh 0.9 to 2.0 kg
4. Wing chord: Measures 32.5 to 44.5 cm from wrist to tip
5. Sexual dimorphism: Females consistently outsize males across all dimensions

Red-tailed hawks possess that gives them an edge when hunting or scanning for prey.

Red-shouldered Hawk Measurements

You’ll notice the red-shouldered hawk (Buteo lineatus) presents smaller dimensions than its red-tailed cousin.

This hawk species measures 43 to 61 cm in body length, with a wing span ranging from 94 to 111 cm. Body mass usually falls between 486 and 774 grams, though some individuals reach 930 grams.

Tail length spans 16 to 24 cm, and the tarsus (leg size) measures 7.5 to 9 cm.

For more details about its identification, habitat, and conservation status, visit the Red-shouldered hawk information page.

Size Comparison and Sexual Dimorphism

Beyond those baseline measurements, body size variance reveals distinct patterns when you compare these hawk species directly. Sexual dimorphism shows females outweighing males by 15 to 25 percent in both red-tailed hawk and red-shouldered hawk populations, with gender-based morphology affecting hunting capacity. Wing span difference translates to greater glide efficiency in females, while maturity growth rates show females reaching full size 6 to 8 weeks earlier.

The differences in size and morphology between males and females have several effects on their behavior and physical abilities:

1. Females deliver deeper wing beats during high-lift glides due to greater mass
2. Males achieve faster peak flight speed with their lighter bodies
3. Size dimorphism effects enable larger females to subdue bigger prey animals
4. Wing loading remains lower in females despite increased body mass relative to wing area

Habitat and Geographic Range

Where you find these red-tailed hawks tells you almost as much about them as their field marks do. Red-tailed hawks claim wide-open territories across nearly all of North America, while red-shouldered hawks stick to wooded areas with much tighter geographic boundaries.

Let’s break down where each species lives, how their ranges overlap, and what landscapes you’ll need to explore to spot them.

Preferred Habitats of Each Species

If you’re chasing hawks through varied terrain, you’ll notice habitat tells the whole story. Red-tailed hawks dominate open country—grasslands, agricultural fields, and forest edge zones where they scan for prey from isolated perches.

If you’re exploring the Northeast, understanding which backyard birds of Rhode Island share these open habitats can sharpen your raptor identification skills year-round.

Red-shouldered hawks prefer woodland habitats with closed canopies, especially riparian zones along rivers and swamps where amphibians thrive. Urban wildlife increasingly includes both species, though red-tails favor fragmented landscapes while red-shoulders cling to preserved forest corridors.

Distribution Across North America

Across North America, you’ll find red-tailed hawks nearly everywhere—from central Alaska south through Mexico into Panama, covering grasslands, deserts, and forest edges. Red-shouldered hawks claim a smaller territory, concentrated in eastern forests from southern Canada to Florida, with a separate Pacific coast population in California.

Their geographic range reflects distinct climate zones:

1. Red-tails span subarctic to subtropical regions
2. Red-shoulders favor temperate forested lowlands
3. Migration patterns differ—northern red-tails move south while western red-shoulders stay put
4. Urban habitats now host both species where mature trees meet open country

Regional densities vary dramatically, with red-tails dominating Great Plains corridors while red-shoulders concentrate in southeastern bottomlands and coastal California.

Overlapping and Distinct Ranges

Throughout eastern forests from Minnesota to Florida, you’ll encounter both species where woodlands meet open country—the primary zone of geographic overlap. Habitat fragmentation has shifted these ecological boundaries, favoring red-tailed hawks in patchwork landscapes while red-shouldered hawks hold riparian corridors.

Understanding range dynamics reveals how species interaction plays out across seasonal migration patterns and changing wildlife distribution.

Geographic Zone	Red-tailed Hawk	Red-shouldered Hawk
Western deserts & grasslands	Common year-round	Absent
Eastern mixed forests	Present in clearings	Dominant in mature woods
Pacific coastal woodlands	Widespread	Resident California population
Central American lowlands	Extends to Panama	doesn’t occur
Overlap regions	Uses field edges	Prefers wooded wetlands

Plumage and Identification Features

When you’re trying to tell these hawks apart in the field, plumage gives you the most reliable clues.

The patterns on their tails, wings, and bodies create distinct visual signatures that remain consistent even when the birds are soaring high overhead.

Understanding how adult and juvenile birds differ will sharpen your identification skills and prevent common mix-ups.

Tail and Wing Patterns

When you’re comparing tail colors between these raptor species, you’ll notice adult red-tailed hawks display a rich rufous tail with minimal banding, while red-shouldered hawks show narrow black and white bands running the full tail length.

In flight, red-shouldered hawks reveal distinctive translucent pale crescents near their wing tips—bright “windows” that red-tailed hawks completely lack in their more uniformly colored primaries.

Body and Underpart Coloration

You’ll spot the most striking underpart difference in breast color—adult red-tailed hawks show a pale cream breast with a dark belly band of streaks below, while red-shouldered hawks display rich rufous coloration from throat to belly.

The red-shouldered hawk’s fine white barring creates even, ladder-like patterns across its underparts, whereas red-tailed hawks present irregular blotchy markings concentrated mid-belly.

Juvenile Vs. Adult Markings

Juvenile plumage development follows distinct timelines in both species, with feather patterns transforming dramatically through the molting process.

You’ll notice young red-tailed hawks lack the signature brick-red tail for roughly 18 months, showing brown tails with narrow dark bands instead.

Juvenile red-shouldered hawks display vertical brown streaking below rather than the rufous barring of adults, making age identification straightforward once you recognize these coloration changes.

Behavior and Diet Comparison

Beyond physical differences, these two hawks behave quite differently in the field—and that’s often what helps you tell them apart when they’re moving through their territory.

From what they hunt to how they communicate, their behavioral patterns reveal distinct strategies shaped by their preferred habitats. Let’s break down the key differences in hunting, vocalizations, and nesting that make each species unique.

Hunting Strategies and Prey Selection

You’ll notice these hawk species split their hunting worlds down the middle—red-tailed hawks perch on open posts and soar over fields targeting mammals, while red-shouldered hawks weave through forests near water hunting amphibians and crayfish. This prey preference shapes everything from flight tactics to scavenging behavior, with red-tails often feeding on roadkill and red-shoulders sticking to live prey.

Hunting Adaptations	Red-tailed Hawk	Red-shouldered Hawk
Perch Hunting	High, open posts and fence lines over grasslands	Mid-level branches near streams and wetlands
Flight Tactics	Soaring at altitude, steep stoops onto ground prey	Low flights along forest edges, quick drops
Prey Preferences	Voles, rabbits, ground squirrels, carrion	Frogs, crayfish, toads, live aquatic prey

Vocalizations and Calls

Beyond the hunting field, vocalizations carve sharp lines between these hawk species. Red-tailed hawks deliver that Hollywood scream—a hoarse, rasping “kee-eeeee-arr” that drops in pitch and usually comes solo or in short bursts during territorial flights. Red-shouldered hawks fire off brighter, sharper “kee-aah” call patterns in rapid strings, creating urgent, ringing chants that echo through forest canopies, especially during breeding season when bird communication peaks.

Red-tailed hawks scream that iconic Hollywood rasp, while red-shouldered hawks fire off sharp, rapid chants through the forest canopy

Vocal Characteristics	Redtailed Hawk	Redshouldered Hawk
Call Tone	Rough, buzzy, cinematic scream	Sharp, clear, piercing whistle
Sound Frequency	Single or 2-3 spaced screams	Long rapid bursts, repeated phrases
Audio Identification	“Kee-eeeee-arr” descending pitch	“Kee-aah” two-note urgent wailing
Vocal Range	2-3 second duration, raspy texture	Evenly spaced, insistent chanting
Bird Identification	Less talkative, dramatic isolated cries	More vocal, persistent forest calls

Breeding and Nesting Habits

When breeding seasons arrive, nest site selection splits these hawks by habitat. Red-tailed hawks crown tall trees or rocky cliff ledges with bulky stick platforms visible across open country, while red-shouldered hawks tuck modest nests into trunk forks within dense riparian forests. Both species reuse nests year after year, refurbishing the same structures through long-term pair bonds that anchor hawk courtship rituals and fledging patterns to familiar territory.

Nesting Trait	Red-tailed Hawk	Red-shouldered Hawk
Nest Location	Tall tree crowns, cliffs, towers	Mid-canopy forks near water
Nest Height	40-120 feet above ground	35-65 feet in forest shade
Fledging Age	42-46 days before first flight	35-42 days, forest-dependent

Tips for Birdwatchers and Identification

Once you know what to look for, telling these two hawks apart in the field becomes second nature. The trick is focusing on the right combination of visual markers, behavioral cues, and timing observations when each species is most active.

Let’s break down the practical strategies you can use to confidently identify red-tailed and red-shouldered hawks during your next outing.

Key Field Marks to Observe

When you’re identifying these hawk species in the field, focus on the tail’s banding pattern—bold black-and-white bars signal a Red-Shouldered Hawk, while the Red-Tailed Hawk displays that iconic brick-red tail.

Check the wing shapes and translucent comma marks on Red-shouldered wings, plus the distinct patagial bar on Red-tailed underwings, to confirm your bird species identification confidently.

Distinguishing Behaviors in The Wild

Watch how Red-tailed Hawks hunt from exposed perches, soaring with broad wings over open territory, while Red-shouldered Hawks ambush prey from dense woodland branches with more agile, stealthy flight patterns. During mating rituals and territorial displays, you’ll hear Red-shouldered Hawks call frequently—their piercing “kee-ah” contrasts sharply with the Red-tailed’s longer, raspy three-noted scream.

When and Where to Spot Each Hawk

You’ll find Red-tailed Hawks year-round across most continental regions, soaring over fields and perched on roadside poles from late morning through mid-afternoon.

Red-shouldered Hawks prefer forested wetlands in the eastern United States and California coast, with seasonal sightings peaking during migration patterns at hawk watchpoints like Hawk Mountain—northern populations winter southward, creating distinct geographic hotspots for birding tips and wildlife habitat exploration.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)