Types of Bird Seed Mix: 9 Proven Ways to Attract More Backyard Birds 2025

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

You’ll find several types of bird seed mix to attract feathered friends to your yard.

Black oil sunflower seeds are the gold standard, drawing cardinals, chickadees, and finches with their high oil content. Nyjer seeds work like magnets for goldfinches, while safflower seeds attract cardinals while deterring squirrels.

Millet appeals to ground-feeding birds like sparrows and juncos. Peanuts bring woodpeckers and jays to the feast.

The best mixes combine these ingredients based on your local birds’ preferences. Some premium types of bird seed mix even include dried fruits and nuts for extra nutrition during those energy-demanding winter months, making them a great option for attracting feathered friends and providing high oil content.

Bird Seed Mix Types

You’ll find that choosing the right bird seed mix can transform your backyard into a bustling bird paradise with minimal effort.

From black oil sunflower seeds that attract cardinals and finches to specialty mixes with nyjer and safflower that bring in unique visitors, each type serves a specific purpose in your bird-feeding strategy.

Black Oil Sunflower Seed

Black oil sunflower seed is the cornerstone of any quality bird seed mix with its high oil content making it irresistible to backyard birds.

You can find quality black oil sunflower products online.

Store in cool, dry places to prevent spoilage.

Striped Sunflower Seed

Alongside black oil varieties, striped sunflower seeds are an economical option for your feeder lineup.

You can find striped sunflower seed products.

With their thick shells, they’re nature’s perfect squirrel deterrent while attracting larger birds like cardinals and blue jays.

You’ll notice these seeds contain less fat than their black oil cousins but still deliver essential nutrients. Their tougher exterior makes them challenging for smaller birds but perfect for those with stronger beaks.

Safflower Seed

While sunflower seeds attract many birds, safflower seed offers a special advantage.

This cardinal favorite has a thick shell and bitter taste that acts as a natural squirrel deterrent.

You’ll find safflower in quality bird seed mix types, providing high protein for your feathered friends.

Cardinals, chickadees, and grosbeaks love cracking open these nutritious seeds. Try mixing safflower with other wild bird seed mix ingredients initially to encourage birds to try it.

Nyjer Seed

While safflower keeps unwanted visitors away, Nyjer seed (also called thistle) works like a magnet for finches.

This tiny black seed packs a powerful nutritional punch in just a small package.

Finches are particularly drawn to Nyjer seed due to its high fat content and suitability for bird seed types.

Peanuts

While nyjer seeds attract finches with their tiny size, peanuts bring the bigger birds to your yard.

You’ll find peanuts in premium bird seed mixes in various forms – whole, chopped, or as "peanut pickouts" in fruit and nut blends.

High in protein and essential fats, they’re like energy bars for birds, especially woodpeckers, jays, chickadees, and nuthatches who can’t resist these nutritional powerhouses.

You can find a variety of peanut bird seed products online.

Seed Nutrition Benefits

You’ll boost your backyard birds’ health by offering seeds packed with the fats, proteins, and carbs they need for energy, feather growth, and strong immune systems.

Different seeds provide unique nutritional benefits, with sunflower seeds offering 40% fat and 16% protein while nyjer seeds contain 36% fat and an impressive 21% protein that helps birds thrive year-round, which is crucial for their strong immune systems.

High Energy Seeds

Now that you’ve learned about different seed types, let’s look at what fuels your backyard visitors.

High energy seeds are bird favorites, especially during cold months when calories matter most.

• Black oil sunflower seeds pack a whopping 9 calories per gram with 40-45% oil content
• Nyjer seeds contain 40% oil in their tiny packages – perfect for finches’ high-energy needs
• Peanuts deliver 5-6 calories each, making them premium "bird fuel" for woodpeckers and jays

Protein Rich Seeds

The protein powerhouses of your bird feeder include black oil sunflower seeds with an impressive 24-25% protein content and peanuts containing up to 28%.

Your feathered friends need these nutrients for healthy feather development and muscle maintenance.

Nyjer seeds offer 20-24% protein in a tiny package perfect for finches, while safflower provides 16-18% protein while deterring unwanted visitors like starlings.

For maximum nutrition, mix these protein-rich options in your feeders, including black oil sunflower seeds.

Healthy Fats

Birds thrive on the energy-packed fats found in high-quality seeds.

Black oil sunflower seeds stand out with 40% fat content, providing essential fatty acids for feather maintenance.

Nyjer seeds offer an impressive 30-40% oil content in a tiny package—perfect for finches.

Peanuts deliver concentrated energy at 49% fat, while safflower (38% fat) supports cardiovascular health.

Consider bird seed nutrition advice for a balanced diet.

Even suet cakes, made from beef fat, provide vital energy during cold weather.

Choosing Best Bird Seeds

You’ll attract more diverse birds to your yard when you match the right seeds to your local species’ preferences.

Choosing fresh, high-quality seed mixes and rotating them seasonally guarantees your feathered visitors return again and again, which is crucial for creating a welcoming environment for birds to return again and again.

Bird Species Preferences

The key to attracting specific birds lies in understanding their seed preferences. Different species have distinct taste preferences that can make or break your backyard bird-watching experience.

Different birds have their own seed preferences—knowing these is your secret to a thriving backyard bird sanctuary.

Here are 5 bird species and their favorite seeds:

1. Cardinals love safflower and sunflower seeds
2. Finches flock to nyjer seeds and small sunflower kernels
3. Woodpeckers prefer peanuts and suet
4. Jays enjoy larger striped sunflower seeds and peanuts
5. Bluebirds are attracted to mealworms rather than seeds

Understanding these preferences is crucial for a successful backyard bird-watching experience.

Seasonal Seed Rotation

Now that you know which birds prefer what seeds, let’s talk about changing your seed offerings throughout the year.

Your feathered friends have different needs as seasons change. Winter requires more calorie-dense options, while summer calls for lighter fare.

Understanding the best birdseed options is vital for their survival.

Season	Best Seed Mix	Key Benefit
Winter	60% sunflower/peanuts	10% more calories for warmth
Spring/Summer	Reduced millet/corn	Prevents spoilage in humidity
Migration	High-fat blends	Supports traveling birds

The table highlights the best seed mix for each season, ensuring you provide the right nutrients for the birds’ changing needs, and by choosing the right seeds, you can support their survival and well-being throughout the year.

Freshness and Quality

Most bird seed mixes lose freshness after 6 months, even in perfect storage conditions.

You’ll want to check for vibrant colors and firm textures when selecting premium bird seed mix. Avoid packages with musty odors or shriveled seeds.

Proper seed storage in airtight containers prevents moisture and insect problems.

The best bird seed mix maintains under 6% moisture content, ensuring superior bird health and feeding enjoyment.

Top 9 Bird Seed Mixes

You’ll find the perfect mix to fill your feeders and watch your yard come alive with colorful visitors in our top 9 bird seed selections.

These proven mixes attract everything from tiny finches to striking cardinals, giving you the best chance to enjoy a bustling backyard bird sanctuary this year.

1. Wagner 25 lb Black Oil Sunflower Bird Seed

View On Amazon
The Wagner 25 lb Black Oil Sunflower Bird Seed delivers serious bang for your buck. You’ll attract a wide variety of feathered visitors thanks to the thin-shelled seeds that even small-beaked birds can crack open easily.

At $15.98, this American-made bag costs about the same as smaller options while lasting much longer. Customers rave about the high quality and lack of debris.

The high energy content supports bird health year-round, especially in winter. Just be aware that this popular seed might also bring squirrels to your yard—they can’t resist it either, which could be a consideration for the bird health.

Best For: Bird enthusiasts looking for an affordable, high-quality seed that attracts a variety of birds year-round.

2. Wagner Striped Sunflower Wild Bird Seed 5 lb

View On Amazon
For larger songbirds with stronger beaks, Wagner Striped Sunflower Wild Bird Seed is your go-to option.

This 5-pound bag features thicker-shelled seeds that cardinals, blue jays, woodpeckers, and titmice love to crack open.

You’ll appreciate the dust-free, fresh quality with no debris mixed in.

The seeds work best in tray or hopper feeders and can be mixed with safflower for variety.

While some customers note a price increase recently, many still report excellent bird attraction.

It’s made in the USA and comes in a mindful package to maintain freshness.

Best For: Larger songbirds like cardinals, blue jays, and woodpeckers, as well as wildlife enthusiasts looking to attract desirable bird species.

3. Lyric No Waste Sunflower Wild Bird Seed 25 lb

View On Amazon
You’ll get more bang for your buck with Lyric No Waste Sunflower Wild Bird Seed. This 25-pound bag contains 100% edible ingredients—whole and split sunflower kernels with no shells or fillers.

Your backyard guests will love the high protein and fat content that fuels their daily activities. Since there are no hulls, you won’t deal with messy cleanup or unwanted sprouting under your feeders.

It works in various feeder types and attracts a wide range of species. Just keep in mind that squirrels and crows find it irresistible too!

Best For: Bird enthusiasts looking to attract a variety of species without the mess of hulls or unwanted sprouting.

4. Wagner 57075 Safflower Seed Wild Bird Food 5 lb

View On Amazon
Many bird enthusiasts swear by Wagner 57075 Safflower Seed as their secret weapon against squirrel problems.

This 5-pound bag attracts cardinals, chickadees, and finches while naturally deterring squirrels, grackles, and starlings.

You’ll appreciate its high oil content that provides essential energy for your backyard visitors, especially during colder months.

The thick-shelled seeds work best in platform or hopper feeders.

For best results, introduce safflower gradually if your birds aren’t familiar with it.

The sturdy packaging helps keep seeds fresh, though some customers mention occasional shipping damage to the sturdy packaging.

Best For: Bird enthusiasts seeking to attract cardinals, chickadees, and other songbirds while discouraging squirrels and nuisance birds.

5. Wagner 62053 20 Pound Nyjer Seed Bird Food

View On Amazon
For serious finch enthusiasts, Wagner 62053 20 Pound Nyjer Seed Bird Food delivers exceptional quality that little birds can’t resist.

Wagner’s Nyjer seed offers little finches a premium feast they simply can’t resist—pure gold for serious bird enthusiasts.

Understanding birdseed types and preferences is vital for attracting specific species.

You’ll notice these tiny black seeds are extra clean and remarkably fresh – essential since finches turn their beaks up at old, brownish nyjer. The ziplock closure helps maintain freshness, while the high oil content provides essential energy for goldfinches and other small songbirds.

Though the price has increased recently, you’ll save compared to local stores. Use specialized sock feeders with small holes to prevent waste, and watch as mourning doves clean up any fallen seeds below, which is a great way to attract goldfinches and other small songbirds.

Best For: Bird enthusiasts who want a high-quality seed to attract finches, goldfinches, and other small songbirds while minimizing waste.

6. Kaytee 5 lb Peanuts In Shell

View On Amazon
Looking for a high-energy treat that brings wildlife to your yard? Kaytee’s 5 lb Peanuts In Shell delivers protein-packed nutrition that birds and small mammals love.

These whole peanuts attract woodpeckers, jays, cardinals, and nuthatches, plus they’re irresistible to squirrels and chipmunks. The natural shells help preserve freshness while providing enrichment as birds work to crack them open.

You’ll get about 2,800 calories per pound, making them perfect for winter feeding and breeding season. The resealable packaging keeps them fresh, and they’re less prone to spoilage than shelled options, which is a significant advantage for protein-packed nutrition and overall value, considering the high-energy treat.

Best For: Backyard birdwatchers and wildlife enthusiasts looking to attract species like woodpeckers, jays, and squirrels while providing high-energy nutrition.

7. Lyric No Waste Wild Bird Seed 15 lb

View On Amazon
A tidier yard awaits with Lyric No Waste Wild Bird Seed.

These 15 pounds of shelled peanut pieces attract bluebirds, chickadees, woodpeckers, and many other songbirds without leaving shells behind.

You’ll save time on cleanup while birds get 100% edible, high-protein food they love.

It works with most feeders, though you’ll need ones with holes large enough for peanuts.

Remember to check for mold after rain.

While slightly pricier than regular mixes, you’re not paying for shells birds discard anyway.

Many customers keep coming back, reporting that birds prefer these over regular seed, making it a great choice for those who want 100% edible food and are willing to pay a bit more for shelled peanut pieces and the convenience of no waste.

Best For: Backyard bird enthusiasts who want a no-mess, 100% edible, high-protein feed that attracts a variety of songbirds.

8. Non GMO Dried Mealworms Chicken Treats 5 lb

View On Amazon
These protein-packed dried mealworms are a game-changer for your backyard bird station.

At 5 pounds, you’ll have plenty to attract bluebirds, woodpeckers, and mockingbirds that might ignore regular seed mixes.

They’re non-GMO and free from preservatives, additives, and dust—plus they don’t need refrigeration.

Customers report seeing more variety in their yard after adding these to their feeding routine.

Try mixing them with seeds and suet or setting up a separate mealworm feeder.

For best results, put them out later in the afternoon to reduce starling consumption.

Best For: Backyard bird enthusiasts and chicken keepers looking to provide a high-protein treat that attracts a variety of birds while supporting feather and egg production.

9. Pine Tree Farms Peanut Butter Suet Cakes 12 Pack

View On Amazon
While other seed options attract certain birds, Pine Tree Farms Peanut Butter Suet Cakes bring woodpeckers, chickadees, and nuthatches flocking to your yard.

Each case includes twelve 5×5-inch cakes packed with rendered beef suet and chopped peanuts.

Hang these energy-rich treats in a suet feeder at least 5 feet above ground for best results.

During cold months, birds will thank you for this high-fat fuel that helps them maintain body temperature.

Though slightly pricier than alternatives, customers report birds consume these cakes more readily than cheaper brands, making them a worthwhile investment for bird enthusiasts and those seeking high-quality suet cakes.

Best For: Backyard bird enthusiasts who want to attract a variety of suet-loving birds, especially during colder months.

Creating Custom

Creating your own bird seed mix gives you complete control over what goes into your backyard buffet.

Five simple ingredients can form the foundation of an effective DIY bird seed mix: black oil sunflower seeds (40%), safflower seeds (25%), nyjer seeds (15%), peanuts (10%), and dried mealworms (10%). This blend ratio attracts a wide variety of birds while providing balanced nutrition.

For supplemental ingredients, consider adding dried fruits like raisins or cranberries to attract fruit-loving species. Budget considerations matter—you can adjust ratios based on what’s affordable while maintaining nutritional value.

Store your homemade bird seed mix in airtight containers in a cool, dry place to prevent mold growth. Always check feeder compatibility with your seed blend; nyjer seeds require special feeders with tiny holes.

The best part? You’ll know exactly what your feathered friends are eating!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)